Bringing doctors together

or

A free, private network for verified physicians

Leading voices

Dr. Stefan Wheat

General Emergency Medicine · UW

View

Dr. Ryan Stanton

General Emergency Medicine · ACEP

View

Dr. Jim Dahle

General Emergency Medicine · The White Coat Investor

View

Dr. Mohamed Hagahmed

General Emergency Medicine · University of Pittsburgh

View

Dr. Sorabh Khandelwal

General Emergency Medicine · OSU

View

Dr. Jennifer Wiler

General Emergency Medicine · UCD

View

Dr. Gita Pensa

General Emergency Medicine · Brown University

View

Dr. Heidi Best

General Emergency Medicine · Emergency Physicians of Tidewater

View

Dr. Kimberly Chernoby

General Emergency Medicine · GW

View

Dr. Amal Mattu

General Emergency Medicine · UMSOM

View
  • Discover your community

  • Stay current

  • A profile that represents you

  • Find your people

About RoonPrivacyTerms

    Overview

    American Heart Association Automated External Defibrillator Symposium: Summary and Recommendations.

    Mar 19, 2025DOI: 10.1161/jaha.124.039291Journal ArticleAHA

    Written by: José G CabañasComilla SassonBenjamin S AbellaTom P AufderheideLance B BeckerKatie N DaintyCarolina Malta-HansenRudolph W KosterMichael C KurzKeith A MarillMaureen O'ConnorAshish R PanchalJon C RittenbergerDavid D SalcidoMichael R SayrePaul SnobelenMonique A StarksDianne L Atkins

    Find these authors on Roon

    CS
    Dr. Comilla Sasson
    General Emergency Medicine · CU Anschutz Medical Campus

    SYMPOSIUM STRUCTURE

    The symposium was organized by members of the AHA Emergency Cardiovascular Care Committee. The program included an opening keynote speaker that summarized the historical background of PAD, while providing a vision into the future. Speakers included invited subject matter experts from the FDA, industry, clinicians, and scientists. This was followed by panel discussions focused on access, patient and community awareness, human factors, and science and technology to shorten the time interval to successful defibrillation. Each panel had a designated moderator to facilitate dialogue between the audience and speakers to foster interactive discussions. The program also included small‐group breakout sessions on human factors to provide a more direct experience and understanding for participants on how human interaction influences systems and processes designed to achieve the desired outcome. Feedback was collected through pre‐ and post‐event interactive surveys to generate a priority list of focus areas to address gaps over the short‐ and long‐term. The summit proceedings were recorded for debriefing purposes and to summarize key content for wider dissemination or future reference. The summary of each panel discussion is presented here as current state, gaps identified and a summary table of recommendations.The symposium brought together participants who share the fundamental aspiration that every community, regardless of socioeconomic factors and geographic location, should have equitable and timely access to AEDs. A key aspect of examining the future use of AEDs was to rethink how PAD programs may improve OHCA outcomes, but also help mitigate historical disparities in access to defibrillation and bystander CPR. Bringing together a broad and diverse group of participants allows for the development of a roadmap that is needed to influence and coordinate meaningful change across all the areas of focus in this symposium (Figure 1).

    SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY

    This panel focused on the current state of the FDA's guidance for AED manufacturers, as well as the need for updated recommendations from the scientific community to inform revised FDA guidance.The AHA Task Force on External Defibrillation, its subcommittee on AED Safety and Efficacy and the AED Manufacturers' Panel published recommendations for rhythm algorithm performance, incorporating new waveforms and enhancing safety to ensure safe use in public access defibrillation settings in 1997.3 The recommendations of this landmark paper continue to serve as the core guide for manufacturers working in the development of new technology and devices and directs FDA approval. However, it has become increasingly clear that the recommendations are no longer adequate for manufacturers or the FDA.
    Given the advances in technological innovation in other industries, AED design continues to lag and has not changed dramatically in the past 30 years. Most AEDs do not currently include geolocation services which can easily identify AED location and integrate them into the 9‐1‐1 system. The use of automated notification would allow nearby lay responders to provide rapid response before emergency medical services (EMS) arrival. Secondly, most currently available AEDs are not able to identify shockable rhythms and deliver shocks during compressions, requiring long pauses during rhythm identification. If available, such new technology can increase chest compression fraction and shorten the pre‐shock delay.6 In addition, AEDs are not currently interoperable with each other or with electronic health record systems creating a barrier to access. As such, the rhythms identified in the field before hospital arrival may not be available to health care personnel who are making determinations about short‐ and long‐term therapy. This lack of information to the treating physicians results in being unaware of the true cause of the collapse and potentially withholding appropriate therapy such as implantation of an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD).7, 8
    Table 1 summarizes the key recommendations related to science and technology identified during the AED Symposium.
    Recommendations on Science and Technology
    Review performance recommendations from Kerber et al
    Distinction between coarse and fine ventricular fibrillation
    Requirement for sensitivity and specificity of rhythms rarely seen during cardiac arrest, ie, NSR
    Regulations require small sample sizes
    No criteria for rhythm identification in the pediatric population
    30–45 s required for rhythm identification
    Update Kerber paper
    Update AED performance standards for sample size, number of sample rhythms per patient, limit to actual rhythms of cardiac arrest
    Need for faster algorithms and shorter times to annotate rhythms during pauses
    Develop sensitivity and specificity criteria for rare or unlikely rhythms that will not present in cardiac arrest
    Validate the rhythm algorithms for pediatric population
    Most waveforms are based on existing waveforms with 20+ y of clinical use
    Research supporting defibrillation waveforms needs to be updated
    Update waveforms to the science of 2024
    Provide more than a single option for defibrillation energy/waveform
    Update technology to account for artifact detection to include rhythm identification during chest compressions
    AEDs are deployed mostly at fixed facilities that are not interconnected with the community nor the public
    Majority of AED use data are simply lost and never used to study, analyze, and to promote new discoveries
    Equip AEDs with web and cellular connectivity to
    Enable GPS tracking, which could be wrapped into leading mobile apps like Google Maps to locate the nearest AED to the public, 911 dispatchers, and EMS personnel
    Wireless transmission of results to receiving hospital or central location or repository
    AED registry
    Make recommendations on standard case reporting and simple report extraction from AED through USB port or Bluetooth
    AED indicates automated external defibrillators; and NSR, non‐shockable rythm

    HUMAN FACTORS

    Humans are the end‐users of AEDs in the field and, as such, are an integral part of ensuring AED design allows for lay responders to use the device safely and appropriately during stressful situations.
    The FDA published guidance for medical device manufacturers in 2016, “Applying Human Factors and Usability Engineering to Medical Devices,” which provides recommended methodology for human factors validation studies when providing evidence to the Agency that a device can be used safely and effectively for the intended users, uses, and use environments.9 The FDA also has recommendations for medical device manufacturers to consider when developing their human factors validation protocol for AEDs to be used by lay responders. A critical task for a device is defined as, “A user task which, if performed incorrectly or not performed at all, would or could cause serious harm to the patient or user, where harm is defined to include compromised medical care.” In the context of AEDs, examples of these critical tasks are: removal of patient clothing, appropriate pad/electrode placement, not touching the patient when delivering a shock, and time to treatment (eg, shock) delivery. For example, as compared with other medical device usability assessments, the FDA guidance recommends medical device manufacturers include a timing component in the success criteria when assessing the usability of AEDs. Time to treatment delivery is especially critical when considering AED use by lay rescuers because timeliness of treatment is directly related to successful outcomes. Furthermore, medical device manufacturers should consider including human factors in the validation studies, stratified user groups such as older and younger lay participants, a purchaser group, and a representative lay responder group. Ultimately, by assessing all critical tasks in the human factors validation study, medical device manufacturers are providing evidence to the Agency that the risk mitigations are effective in preventing critical use errors.
    The FDA relies heavily on the MAUDE (Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience) database to analyze incoming device reports by mandatory reporters (manufacturers, importers, and device user facilities) and voluntary reporters such as health care professionals, patients and consumers. This serves as the basis for identifying critical issues that may impact device function. However, ongoing research showcases how important qualitative research and real‐time case data may be in understanding more granular issues with AEDs. Data presented by Peel Regional Paramedic Services in Ontario, Canada gathered through the use of the Lay Responder debriefing program10 exemplify how the real‐world experience of using an AED by lay rescuers can provide critical insights into more human‐centered design of the devices.11 Unlike fire extinguishers, a common comparison, every AED on the market is designed with different cases, covers, and screens, different voice prompts, order of the prompts, and overall inconsistent imagery, naming conventions, or language. To make AEDs easier to use, their design must be simple, transparent, and standardized. Then, when education and training is deployed in the community, people should feel confident that the available AED will be recognizable in a time‐sensitive, highly stressful situation.
    Research from simulation‐based studies assessing a lay rescuers' abilities to accurately use AEDs is critical to improve design. Comparisons of different AEDs have shown that user‐friendliness was significantly different across different models. This was highlighted by interviewing laypersons after use of AEDs in a simulated setting showing that intuitiveness and improved visual cues were considered important by laypersons.12 For example, poor imagery of electrode placement on the device, resulting in less effective shock delivery was reported by both lay rescuers and health care professionals. The illustrations on the electrodes show inaccurate placement with the lateral pad in the anterior axillary line, rather than mid‐axillary. In addition, following defibrillation, some laypersons remove the electrodes after only 1 shock or do not resume chest compressions. This may be related to inadequate training or uncontextualized translation of abbreviations into other languages. Moreover, these issues are only compounded when simulations include activation of the pediatric mode to defibrillate because of different solutions from various manufacturers (separate electrodes or buttons in the device).
    To date, there has been a lack of integration of human factors research to inform a more robust understanding of how consumers use AEDs in real‐world settings. Such research could make AEDs more acceptable to the public, more user‐friendly and ensure that skill training transfers directly to real‐life situations when users are under duress.
    Table 2 summarizes the key recommendations related to human factors identified during the AED Symposium.
    Recommendations on Human Factors
    Better real‐world data collection using qualitative and quantitative methods
    Research on stratified groups who are more likely to have difficulty with the device (eg, older, younger, non‐English speaking)
    Standardization of AED look and feel
    Design must be transparent, simple, with interoperability of electrodes
    Standard method to activate pediatric mode
    Better visual cues on devices
    Electrodes should be similar in design and application to standardize training
    ‐Standardization of AED voice prompts and ordering
    ‐Ability to “teach to the prompts” in CPR training courses and contextualize training
    AED indicates automated external defibrillators; CPR, cardiopulmonary resuscitation; and MAUDE, Manufacturer and User Facility Device Experience.
    Education and training of lay responders is an integral part of increasing the willingness to respond, critical skills in performing CPR and using the AED, as well as how to handle the stress related to the event.
    Major training organizations like the AHA are focused on providing hands‐on education for lay responders to better understand how to use AEDs. Despite focused training efforts, CPR and AED training has been found to be lower in counties with a higher proportion of rural, Black, Hispanic, and lower income residents.13 The focus is on developing a framework for which community members can anticipate presence of an AED will prompt them to act. However, because of high variability in how AEDs are designed, as well as voice prompts, generic actions are covered in these courses, which may mean that the lay responder may have a completely different interaction with the device in a real‐life situation.11 Finally, equity, diversity, and inclusiveness considerations are absent from current training paradigms and presents significant challenges for certain groups, especially those in underserved and vulnerable populations.
    Summit participants recognized community education and engagement as a critical element to a successful PAD program. The importance of creating a culture of valuing CPR and AED training and use in a community as a whole is a crucial reframing of how we talk about CPR training, and schoolchildren are a target population of interest to drive sustainable change within a population.
    CPR and AED use education can be integrated into school curricula. Schoolchildren, even in the absence of formalized training, have demonstrated successful use of an AED in simulated conditions.14, 15, 16 Schoolteachers are in a unique position to integrate CPR and AED use education in the classroom. Previous research has shown how schoolteachers can teach basic life support content after proper training.14, 15, 16, 17 Summit participants noted that it is important that schoolchildren are a priority population to be educated in CPR and use of an AED. Examples of take‐home resources to help engage and educate schoolchildren were shared at the symposium.
    Table 3 summarizes the key recommendations related to education and training identified during the AED Symposium.
    Recommendations on Education and Training
    Gamification of CPR and AED education
    Student record/report card has a separate course record showing completion of training
    BLS Peer Training
    Engage public school systems
    Legislative efforts to provide funding assistance for CPR and AED training
    Require CPR and AED training as a prerequisite for employment in school systems
    Annual training as part of the educator's professional development pathway
    BLS Peer Training
    Less expensive manikins
    Inexpensive AED trainers
    AED indicates automated external defibrillators; BLS, basic life support, and CPR, cardiopulmonary resuscitation.
    The Emergency Cardiovascular Care Systems of Care subcommittee completed a comprehensive analysis of policies influencing access to AEDs. The policy gap analysis revealed a complex landscape of laws and regulations governing the use of Automated External Defibrillators (AEDs) in public places. Significant heterogeneity was observed across different jurisdictions, highlighting inconsistencies and gaps in standards and requirements (Figure 2). Key findings included variations in AED accessibility mandates, training and certification requirements for AED operators, liability protection for AED use, and reporting obligations. The analysis emphasized the need for harmonization and standardization of AED‐related policies to ensure widespread deployment, effective use, and legal protection in emergency situations across diverse settings. Universal AED public policy would inform training and education efforts which provide the foundation of new interventions to increase bystander participation, including AED utilization as part of an effort to evolve PAD programs.
    AED indicates automated external defibrillators.
    Table 4 summarizes the key recommendations related to policies and regulations during the AED Symposium.
    Recommendations on Policies and Regulations
    ‐Complex, variable, and strict regulations create barriers to AED placement, maintenance, and use
    ‐Liability concerns may deter individuals and organizations from deploying or using AEDs
    ‐Need for harmonization across complex laws and regulations
    ‐Need for clear liability protections
    ‐Federal regulations should serve as a floor, but not a ceiling, for the legal framework across states
    ‐No clear guidance on optimal placement
    ‐AEDs are currently located in buildings that are not necessarily accessible to the public
    ‐Leverage technology to inform deployment
    ‐AED registration locally
    ‐Inclusion of AED locations in telephone apps
    ‐No universal guidance on signage and packaging for deployment
    ‐The current most common AED location is in a cabinet
    ‐Cost, including the expense of AED acquisition, training, and maintenance can limit access
    ‐Optimal deployment strategies must consider equity and account for areas with a higher risk
    ‐Local jurisdictions should offer incentives, grants to expand accessibility
    ‐Placement with 24/7 accessibility
    ‐Lower cost
    ‐Recommend or legislate ILCOR endorsed universal AED signage already in use in many other countries
    ‐Standardization and simplicity on maintenance plans to ensure readiness
    ‐Potential to implement readiness plans based on prevention models created for fire safety and extinguishing devices requiring a regular inspection and testing
    ‐Wi‐Fi notification to inform owners of expiring batteries and pads
    AED indicates automated external defibrillators; and ILCOR, International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation.
    The final panel of the AED Symposium was a presentation of several programs which have developed novel methods to improve PAD within their communities. These sites include the City of San Diego, Denmark, City of Pittsburgh, and Holland. During the presentations, several themes were consistent across the sites. These include wide‐spread CPR education and AED training, high density of availability of AEDs, government buy‐in for the programs, dispatch telephone apps to quickly notify lay rescuers and attention to equity in both CPR training and AED availability. Below are some of the specifics which have made each program unique and successful within their communities. The panel also included a presentation about the potential benefit of drones to deliver AEDs in a timely manner.
    Created in 2001, the goals of the project are to save lives by establishing awareness, education, and making AEDs as accessible as fire extinguishers throughout the city and county of San Diego. Every high school student graduates with compression‐only CPR and AED training. Other unique aspects of the program include use of 30‐second Public Service Announcement videos and social media posts, ability to purchase AEDs at reduced costs, post‐incident management with EMS teams responding to downloaded AED data and provide critical incident debriefing for responders. Since the project's inception, 10 000 AEDs have been distributed and 208 lives, including 5 children have been saved.
    Denmark instituted the Danish AED Network, linking information about individual AEDs to all emergency medical dispatch centers across the country, enabling identification of the nearest accessible AED in the event of an OHCA.18 Their program uses text‐messages or smartphone applications to activate citizen responders and linked them to an available AED. This resulted in a 76% increase in bystander CPR and tripling the rate of bystander defibrillation.19 Dispatching volunteers to the scene of cardiac arrest with AEDs20; optimizing AED placement in the community through spatiotemporal and mathematical modeling21, 22; and new AED smart screens that alert lay rescuers to the event and location of a cardiac arrest were critical factors leading to this change. Publicly available AEDs have increased from 0 to 20 943 since 2006, and AEDs with 24/7 access have increased from 2775 in 2015 to 12 923 in 2021. Through the telephone app, volunteer responders now number 150 000 distributed throughout the entire country. When a citizen responder arrives first, the odds ratio of bystander CPR and defibrillation is 3.73 (2.04–6.84). Additional interventions which support the PAD programs include legislative mandates to report all cardiac arrests to the Danish Cardiac Arrest Registry, CPR training in schools, workplaces and before receiving a driver's license, and public campaigns associated with Restart a Heart Day.
    Holland started their PAD project in 2005 with the adoption of a telephone alert app notifying citizens of a suspected cardiac arrest in both public and private homes. Responders must have an active CPR certification. Refresher courses are required every year to remain active in the program. Two thirds of located volunteers are directed to the AED first, one third directed to the victim to initiate or continue CPR.
    To increase awareness, the Netherlands Heart Foundation supported frequent radio and TV announcements and created a “6 minutes” campaign to encourage local communities to organize themselves with volunteers and AEDs. These volunteers, along with an increased response from first responders, resulted in AED application in >50% of victims before EMS arrival. There has been a reduction of the delay from emergency‐call to first defibrillation from any device (AED or EMS) from 11.7 to 9.3 minutes in residential areas and from 9.2 to 8 minutes in public places. Consequently, survival from OHCA with a shockable rhythm in residential areas (60%–70% of all OHCA) increased from 26% to 39% and in public (38% of all OHCA) remained at 51%.23, 24 This indicates that community rescuers indeed contribute primarily to increased survival of patients in residential areas where most OHCAs occur.
    The PAD program in Pittsburgh also uses a telephone‐dispatch app including a defined and managed responder program, making the distribution of AEDs and trainers equitable across the city, recognizing that residential neighborhoods need coverage even more than commercial areas and that the AEDs can be co‐located with other life‐saving tools, such as Narcan and Stop the Bleed supplies. An ideal responder program includes law enforcement, designated off‐duty responders, as well as the general public. AEDs must be registered to the telephone app with a sustainable system‐level plan for management and maintenance. System analytics are collected from the start to measure the effectiveness of the program and identify underserved or underutilizing in areas. Post‐event surveys including all elements of response (ie, alert received or missed, arrival at scene, chest compressions, locate and/or use AED and psychological stress) are instrumental in improving the program.
    Equity is fundamental to a successful PAD program and every residential neighborhood is different. Thus, any program cannot be “one size fits all” and each neighborhood needs a stakeholder group to own the effort. System analytics from the telephone app has identified the areas at highest risk for cardiac arrest and correlates this with the number of responders and AEDs. Responding to these disparities is crucial to improving outcomes. As geolocation can disincentivize participation within specific populations, the telephone app offers an alternative called AED responders whereby the proximity trigger for an alert is the nearest AED and the geolocation of the responder is not recorded. Within the city of Pittsburgh, bystander CPR in telephone app public associated areas was 60% versus 36% in non‐telephone app associated OHCA.25
    Drones, or unmanned aerial vehicles, hold promise for rapidly delivering AEDs to bystanders for OHCA treatment.26 International research has advanced our understanding of this technology to deliver AEDs in a timely manner first through mathematical optimization research, then simulated drone AED deliveries, and now with real‐time and safe beyond visual line of sight operations within controlled air space. Sweden has done this on more than 200 suspected cardiac arrests.27, 28, 29, 30, 31 The first report of a patient who was successfully defibrillated by a drone‐delivered AED occurred in Sweden in January of 2022.32
    In the United States, simulation research has demonstrated that bystanders can successfully apply and use a drone‐delivered AED with telephone dispatch assistance.33 This study demonstrated that a drone needed to arrive at least 1:59 minutes ahead of EMS in order for the bystander to have time to retrieve, apply, and defibrillate an OHCA patient. Mathematical optimization research demonstrated that a state‐wide drone network, along with first responders carrying an AED, could potentially achieve a median AED arrival time (time from 9‐1‐1 call to AED arrival) of 4.8 (interquartile range, 4.3–5.2) minutes34, 35 with a median of 7 (interquartile range, 5–8) drones per county, with greatest median arrival time benefit in urban areas compared with rural regions.
    There is a growing body of evidence that in a controlled environment in both urban and rural regions drones can deliver an AED faster than the current EMS services. However, the effectiveness of drone delivery of AEDs on improving cardiac arrest survival is currently dependent on resolving several supporting factors including, but not limited to Federal and local aviation regulations, practical considerations of operation and maintenance of a drone network, weather effects on flight operations, community education, AED literacy, the optimal drone model, and cost.

    CONCLUSIONS

    The AED summit successfully brought together a multidisciplinary group of subject matter experts from the FDA, industry, clinicians, and scientists to collaboratively discuss the current state of knowledge, identify gaps, and establish strategic recommendations for the future of AED technology and PAD. These strategic recommendations serve as a roadmap to transform how we think about PAD, AED devices, program implementation, and ultimately improve survival from OHCA.

    Sources of Funding

    The AED Symposium was made possible by the AHA with support from Philips Healthcare, Stryker Corporation, and ZOLL Medical Corporation.

    Disclosures

    Benjamin S. Abella MD MPhil reports research funding from the National Institute Health, Avive, Becton Dickinson, Consulting: Becton Dickinson, Zoll, Stryker, Neuroptics; Tom P. Aufderheide, MD, MS, grants from: The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute and National Institute for Neurological Disorders and Stroke for ARREST Trial and, Influence of Cooling duration on Efficacy in Cardiac Arrest Patients. Zoll Medical inc. for Ventilation Monitoring in Out‐of‐Hospital Emergency Care. Consulting: Medtronics, Inc. Volunteer: Citizen CPR Foundation, Resuscitation Science Symposium Planning Committee, and 3CPR Leadership Committee; Lance B. Becker MD, institutional grants from Nihon Kohden, Philips Medical Systems, and ZOLL Medical Corp. Serves on the scientific advisory boards for Nihon Kohden and Philips; Katie N. Dainty PhD, member Medical Advisory Board for Philips Healthcare; Carolina Malta‐Hansen MD, PhD, grants from TrygFonden, Helsefonden, Independent Research Fund Denmark, Laerdal Foundation, Novo Nordisk Foundation, Capital Region of Denmark Research Fund, Member of International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation Basic Life Support Task Force and RACE‐CARS (Regional Approaches to Cardiovascular Emergencies—Cardiac Arrest) trial steering committee; Rudolph W. Koster, MD, PhD, medical advisor for Stryker Emergency Care (Redmond, WA), and Heartsine (Belfast, UK); Michael R. Sayre, MD, Consultant, Stryker Emergency Care (Redmond, WA); Monique A. Starks MD, MHS, reports grants on AHA Health Equity Research Network—Improving Access to Care and other Health Inequities in Rural America—Developing and Testing Drone‐Delivered AEDs for Cardiac Arrests In Rural America, The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute K23 Award—Evaluation of the Requirements and Critical Features of a Drone‐Deployed AED Network to Improve Community‐Level Survival after out‐of‐hospital cardiac arrest, and UH3 Cluster Randomized Trial, RACE‐CARS. The remaining authors have no disclosures to report.
    CS

    Dr. Comilla Sasson

    Emergency Medicine · General Emergency Medicine
    University of Colorado Anschutz
    comilla