Bringing doctors together

or

A free, private network for verified physicians

Leading voices

Dr. Stefan Wheat

General Emergency Medicine · UW

View

Dr. Ryan Stanton

General Emergency Medicine · ACEP

View

Dr. Jim Dahle

General Emergency Medicine · The White Coat Investor

View

Dr. Mohamed Hagahmed

General Emergency Medicine · University of Pittsburgh

View

Dr. Sorabh Khandelwal

General Emergency Medicine · OSU

View

Dr. Jennifer Wiler

General Emergency Medicine · UCD

View

Dr. Gita Pensa

General Emergency Medicine · Brown University

View

Dr. Heidi Best

General Emergency Medicine · Emergency Physicians of Tidewater

View

Dr. Kimberly Chernoby

General Emergency Medicine · GW

View

Dr. Amal Mattu

General Emergency Medicine · UMSOM

View
  • Discover your community

  • Stay current

  • A profile that represents you

  • Find your people

About RoonPrivacyTerms

    Overview

    The American Heart Association Emergency Cardiovascular Care 2030 Impact Goals and Call to Action to Improve Cardiac Arrest Outcomes: A Scientific Statement From the American Heart Association.

    Jan 22, 2024DOI: 10.1161/cir.0000000000001196Journal ArticleAHA

    Written by: Raina M MerchantLance B BeckerSteven C BrooksPaul S ChanMarina Del RiosMary E McBrideRobert W NeumarJeanette K PrevidiAnezi UzenduComilla SassonAmerican Heart Association

    Find these authors on Roon

    CS
    Dr. Comilla Sasson
    General Emergency Medicine · CU Anschutz Medical Campus

    Introduction

    In 2010, the American Heart Association (AHA) Emergency Cardiovascular Care (ECC) Committee identified specific goals focused on increasing survival from cardiac arrest. Targets for 2020 included 1) training 20 million people per year, 2) doubling bystander response, 3) and doubling out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) and in-hospital cardiac arrest (IHCA) survival. While significant improvements have been achieved over the past decade toward these goals,1 cardiac arrest still remains a major public health problem and the leading cause of mortality and morbidity in the United States.2The 2010 goals provided a roadmap for key strategic areas of focus for improving cardiac arrest outcomes.3 Further, these priorities are used by ECC committees for strategic planning and for ECC organizational aims to make meaningful advancements in creating an ecosystem of training, response, action, and follow-through for the public and for healthcare professionals.This scientific statement identifies key strategic targets for improving cardiac arrest outcomes by 2030. These priorities were developed through an iterative process led by the AHA ECC and described below. The AHA ECC has over 300 volunteers and consists of 3 subcommittees: Science, Education, and Systems of Care, in addition to the Pediatrics Emphasis Group. Members of these committees are leading resuscitation experts representing several disciplines (eg, emergency medicine, medicine, critical care, neurology, pediatrics, surgery, behavioral science) and professional backgrounds (eg, physicians, nurses, paramedics, respiratory technicians, educators) as well as cardiac arrest survivors. Each committee identified target areas in a 2-day, face-to-face meeting with cross-committee discussions. A refined list of target areas and metrics was then reviewed in-depth within committees and presented to the ECC Committee. The list was further refined over a series of meetings across all subcommittees and the Pediatrics Emphasis Group. Table 1 includes targets across adult and pediatric groups with an approximate 10% to 20% proposed increase in survival goals. Each section also includes action strategies that can be advanced by national, state, and local organizations and through partnerships with AHA and other stakeholders (Figure 1).Of note the target areas and metrics in Table 1 were developed relative to data which are accessible in currently available, robustly managed, longitudinal national databases which report information specifically about out-of-hospital and in-hospital cardiac arrest. Our committee recognized that advancing process and outcome measures in cardiac arrest will require expansion of these databases and/or development of new data repositories to include additional information about the multitude of factors that affect cardiac arrest incidence, treatment, and outcomes. In addition to a consistent funding source and governing organization, robust tracking of these measures would require that the data are consistently available, accessible, of high integrity, valid, able to be risk-stratified, and measurable across populations. Table 2 includes aspirational goals for cardiac arrest process and outcome measures that would ideally be available in national databases before or by 2030 to provide more granularity in tracking and improving the range of factors which impact cardiac arrest. This broader list of targets and populations would enable better benchmarking and broader understanding of where resources should be allocated for improving cardiac arrest outcomes. AHA is well positioned to support coordinating existing and future resources and partners to enable data collection and reporting of the areas of focus in the aspirational table with a goal of this information being available by 2030.
    An explicit focus of the AHA ECC 2030 priorities is alignment with the AHA’s 2024 impact goal.4 This specific goal is as follows: “Every person deserves the opportunity for a full, healthy life. As champions for health equity, by 2024, the AHA will advance cardiovascular health for all, including identifying and removing barriers to health care access and quality.”4
    The AHA ECC 2030 impact goals (Table 1) directly align with these organizational goals, with a focus on health equity and ensuring cardiac arrest survival and access to care is equitable for all.
    The confluence of 2 events in 2020 shaped the time horizon and overarching focus of the 2030 priorities. First, the global COVID-19 pandemic has been a major driver of morbidity and mortality across health conditions and the impact on cardiac arrest outcomes has been significant and devastating.5–7 The practice of resuscitation has been severely impacted (e.g. delays and limitations in resuscitation attempts and variability in the implementation of post resuscitation care).8 Resuscitation guidelines have been continually updated to be responsive to these shifts.8, 9
    Healthcare providers had to consider their own risk of contracting COVID-19 in performing all resuscitations and invasive procedures.10–12 Healthcare systems had to balance caring for critically ill patients with and without COVID-19, ensuring that healthcare staff had adequate personal protective equipment and in parallel avoiding COVID-19 transmission to patients with non–COVID-19 medical emergencies or in need of routine medical care. The COVID-19 pandemic fractured healthcare systems’ capacity to care for non–COVID-19 conditions, with substantial consequences. Early identification of cardiovascular emergencies was challenged when outpatient medical care was moved from in-person clinic settings to telehealth and nonurgent clinic appointments were rescheduled or even cancelled. As shelter-in-place orders were adopted by municipalities experiencing COVID-19 surges, EMS systems identified a decrease in calls for cardiovascular emergencies and an increase in patients’ refusal of transport.13, 14 These factors are important contributors to the excess number of cases of OHCA.15, 16 While COVID-19 has had global repercussions, there are significant disparities in how hospitals were impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic due to the tiered nature of the US healthcare system, a structure that impacts the quality of care received by patients from historically marginalized racial and ethnic groups.16–21 The long-term impact that COVID-19 and its sequelae will have on cardiac arrest outcomes and resuscitation remains unknown, but the contribution of hospital-level differences in care and outcomes will need to be further examined. These priorities for the next decade are therefore identified to account for the significant uncertainty in resuscitation practices and outcomes.
    The AHA ECC 2030 priorities were also shaped by a nationwide awakening to the systemic racism in the United States, spurred by the murder of George Floyd and many others by police and the recognition of the Black Lives Matter movement. The COVID-19 pandemic also exposed vulnerabilities and biases within the healthcare system that predated the pandemic and have detrimental effects on how health systems operate and how health outcomes are impacted.18, 22 In addition, the pandemic has led to renewed focus on structural racism being identified as a public health crisis.19 Overall, the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in an unparalleled loss of life numbering in the millions. These deaths have disproportionately impacted Black, Latinx, and Indigenous communities and exacerbated health inequities.20, 23, 24
    Furthermore, inequities in workplace safety, technology literacy, language concordance, and access to healthcare contributed to disproportionate rates of COVID-19 infections, hospitalizations, and deaths in Black, Latinx, and other groups that have been historically marginalized.25–27 These factors have also been contributors to increased incidence of and lower survival following cardiac arrest in the same communities.16, 28 Considering the significant disparities (e.g. race, ethnicity, sex, gender) that exist in bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation (BCPR) rates and cardiac arrest outcomes, the writing group and ECC Committee identified equity as a key focus for evaluating BCPR rates, automated external defibrillator (AED) utilization, and cardiac arrest outcomes over time.
    Cardiac arrest incidence and survival rates vary depending on factors such as location, race, ethnicity.29–33 Black and Latinx individuals have a higher incidence of cardiac arrest and a lower chance of surviving with functional neurologic outcome compared with White individuals.34, 35 The incidence of OHCA increases and the likelihood of survival decreases among residents in lower income populations.36–41 While BCPR can double to triple chances of survival, it is less frequently provided to people who have an OHCA in neighborhoods that are predominantly Black, Latinx, and low income.42–44 Prior reports also support that BCPR may be less frequently provided to women who have suffered a cardiac arrest.45–47 Outcomes after a cardiac arrest also vary widely by hospital, with studies showing that hospitals that provide care for predominantly Black and low-income populations report lower survival rates compared with those that serve higher-income and predominantly White populations.48 Disparities in rates of cardiac catheterization and provision of targeted temperature management have been previously identified as potential reasons for gender and race-related disparities in neurologically favorable survival after cardiac arrest.49–52
    The underlying sources of disparities in the incidence, treatment, survival, and long-term outcomes of cardiac arrest are complex. The higher incidence and lower survival rates of cardiac arrest in Black, Latinx, and other historically marginalized groups are largely a consequence of structural racism. Defined as the “totality of ways in which societies foster racial discrimination, through mutually reinforcing inequitable systems (eg, housing, education, employment, earnings, benefits, credit, media, health care, criminal justice) that in turn reinforce discriminatory beliefs, values, and distribution of resources,” structural racism reinforces and perpetuates health inequities.53
    Rates of cardiovascular disease vary by race and ethnicity,2 which may lead to the higher incidence rates of cardiac arrest in these groups; however, unequal access to preventive health services/screening, delays in diagnosis/treatment, neighborhood-level resources, and unequal access to cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and AED training opportunities also contribute to worse cardiac arrest outcomes in this population.54–61 Inequitable educational and employment opportunities and inequitable distribution of healthcare infrastructure and services lead to shorter life expectancies in people in some under-resourced zip codes compared with their neighbors just a few miles away.62–64 Despite national cardiac arrest treatment guidelines, not all patients receive evidence-based therapies or care, with people from historically marginalized racial and ethnic groups and sex and gender minorities at particularly high risk for undertreatment.50, 52, 65–69 Accordingly, the AHA and AHA ECC have included identifying and removing barriers to health equity in their impact goals and priorities.4, 70
    To eliminate disparities in cardiac arrest incidence, treatment, and survival, it is imperative to describe and measure how interpersonal, structural, and institutional biases negatively affect the health of historically marginalized racial and ethnic groups, rural communities, and low-income communities. There is an opportunity to save more lives by prioritizing equitable delivery of lifesaving interventions throughout the Chain of Survival (Figure 2) and including equitable outcomes as a metric of success. This approach also aligns with the focus of the AHA on promoting strategies for addressing structural racism across multiple domains: advocacy, quality improvement, leadership, human resources/business operations, and science (Figure 3).
    In alignment with AHA’s 2024 goals,4 and in consideration of the persistent disparities in cardiac arrest recognition, treatment, and survival based on race, ethnicity, income, sex, gender, and geographic location (ie, urban, rural), the ECC Committee has included a 2030 Target Priority to eliminate disparities in BCPR, AED use, and survival. The targeted goal rate of BCPR, AED use, and survival by sex, gender, and in racial/ethnic and other historically marginalized groups and communities with low socioeconomic status should at least be equal to that of the general population.
    Action strategies to address disparities (Table 2) need to be centered around identifying barriers in the links of the AHA’s Chain of Survival in order to implement targeted plans to strengthen those links. One barrier to tracking progress in outcomes over time is that cardiac arrest is not currently identified as a reportable condition. Further, a barrier in achieving health equity is lack of data on certain groups (eg, Indigenous, Asians). There is also inconsistency in how gender, race, ethnicity, and socioeconomic status data are obtained and reported. Studies may report this data by geographic designation because obtaining individual level data can be challenging and self-reporting may not be possible in the setting of cardiac arrest.71–73
    Addressing the disproportionate burden of cardiac arrest incidence in lower-income and historically marginalized racial and ethnic groups should start at the societal level, with prevention and screening to identify people at risk of cardiovascular disease and cardiac arrest. Resuscitation training materials could also raise awareness of inequities by specifically including information for end users about historical and current disparities in practice and outcomes for sex, gender, and racial/ethnic and other historically marginalized groups. Moreover, strategies to increase community response must address structural barriers to activating EMS response, such as language competency and mistrust of first responders.74 Basic and advanced life support providers must recognize and address implicit structural and systemic bias to reduce inequities in EMS and hospital interventions. Lastly, there is a need for equal access to resources for post–cardiac arrest care and recovery.
    OHCA is associated with low survival, but early CPR and early defibrillation can improve outcomes.75, 76 Approximately 70% of cardiac arrests occur outside of the hospital setting, where the link for early CPR in the AHA Chain of Survival often lies in the hands of lay rescuers. BCPR has been shown in multiple studies to improve OHCA survival and can double or triple the odds of survival in OHCA.37, 38, 77, 78 Unfortunately, BCPR is only performed in an estimated 40% of US OHCA victims, with lower rates in Black, Latinx, and other historically marginalized racial and ethnic groups.38, 40 Residents living in primarily low-income neighborhoods and/or in neighborhoods with predominately Black and/or Latinx residents are more likely to have OHCA and are less likely to receive BCPR.41, 42 For example, in a study in Los Angeles using the Cardiac Arrest Registry to Enhance Survival (CARES) database, Latinx residents in Los Angeles received BCPR at approximately half the rate of White residents.79 Contributing factors for low rates of BCPR include factors such as: limited access to knowledge about training, fear of making a mistake, fear of disease transmission (which has increased since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic), liability issues,.74, 80, 81 Language barriers and associated challenges due to limited English in 9–1-1 callers during dispatcher-identified cardiac arrest are also associated with less frequent BCPR, as well as delays in both cardiac arrest recognition and implementation of telephone-CPR.66, 82, 83
    Annual rates of CPR training in the United States vary widely across communities, with counties located in the south, those with higher proportions of rural areas, higher proportions of Black and Latinx residents, and lower median household incomes all having lower rates of CPR training than other communities.55, 84
    Prior work has focused on community-based programs to increase knowledge awareness and action in neighborhoods.85–87 One such program was highlighted in a study of 2 cities in Texas, which demonstrated how a geographically targeted CPR training strategy tailored to neighborhood population characteristics may be effective in reducing disparities in BCPR for OHCA.56 High-risk neighborhoods (ie, neighborhoods comprising predominantly low-income residents and historically marginalized ethnic and racial groups) can be identified, and CPR training can be targeted in neighborhoods in which it is most likely to be needed.39, 40, 43, 44, 58 Incentives and support for new training modalities and digital platforms like virtual training, Resuscitation Quality Improvement programs, and CPR kiosks may be able to enhance CPR education and response.88, 89 Recognizing the importance of community involvement in a cardiac arrest program and developing a CPR training program that takes into consideration the uniqueness of each community’s barriers and opportunities can help support implementation of targeted programs focused on education90 and increasing awareness. Training programs should not only center on the mechanics of BCPR but also address community concerns regarding accessing emergency services and preventing disease transmission, especially in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Continued focus on CPR training as a requirement for high school graduation or other settings like obtaining a drivers license represent additional strategies for increasing training.91 Targeted efforts focused on high-risk communities have the potential to improve overall BCPR rates while reducing health disparities in the prevention, recognition, and treatment of cardiac arrest.
    The ECC Committee 2030 Target Priority is to increase the rate of BCPR to more than 50% (2020 CARES: 40.2%) by the end of 2030. The targeted goal rate by sex, gender, and in racial/ethnic and other groups that have been marginalized and communities with low socioeconomic status should at least be equal to that of the general population.
    Action strategies to improve BCPR (Table 2) must 1) address barriers to CPR training and performance, 2) include more robust data collection in order to improve outcomes, and 3) identify and target training in broader settings (e.g. requirement for high school graduation) and communities of highest need to reduce disparities and increase rates of BCPR in all neighborhoods, regardless of race, ethnicity, geography, or socioeconomic status.
    Ventricular fibrillation and pulseless ventricular tachycardia are amenable to defibrillation but deteriorate to nonshockable rhythms over time. The probability of survival from cardiac arrest decreases for every minute defibrillation is delayed.92, 93 Early defibrillation in conjunction with chest compressions is associated with markedly improved survival for people who experience cardiac arrest.94, 95 The median time from 9–1-1 call to scene arrival for EMS responding to OHCA is more than 6 minutes in North America, even in dense urban settings.96 Given these system limitations, use of AEDs as soon as possible by people at the scene is a critical component of the Chain of Survival and a key strategy to optimize outcomes after OHCA. Most contemporary AEDs provide prompts to guide users through the process of CPR, with some even providing real-time feedback on quality.
    Despite the proliferation of public access defibrillation programs, many barriers to early defibrillation for victims of OHCA remain.97 Overall, fewer than 10% of OHCA victims have an AED applied before EMS arrival.95, 96 AEDs are more likely to be used in public settings compared with private residential settings (15.3% versus 1.3%).98 This is a critical issue because approximately 80% of all OHCAs occur in a residential setting.95 Although shockable rhythms are observed less often in residential-location cardiac arrests, the potential population health benefit of early detection and defibrillation for OHCA occurring in residential settings could be significant.99 A specific focus on early defibrillation (and not just public access defibrillation) would enable a broader focus on defibrillation across multiple settings where cardiac arrest occurs and significant improvements in outcomes could occur with targeted strategies in these non-public areas (e.g. home, office, club, industrial areas).
    Access to AEDs and early defibrillation is not uniform.100–106 AEDs require a significant upfront investment to acquire and install the equipment. There are also costs associated with training potential users and ongoing maintenance. Evidence suggests that there are fewer public access AEDs in low-income neighborhoods compared with higher-income neighborhoods.107 AEDs are used less often during cardiac arrests occurring in neighborhoods with lower socioeconomic status.108 Women who experience OHCA in a public location are less likely than men to receive bystander AED use.109 In a prior report, Latinx residents were less likely than White or Black residents to have received AED training.59 Future work is required to understand the systemic and contextual factors contributing to inequity in access to early defibrillation so that effective, targeted solutions can be implemented.
    The ECC Committee 2030 Target Priority is to increase the proportion of individuals with OHCA who have an AED applied before the arrival of EMS to 20% in a public setting (2020 CARES: 9.0%). The targeted goal rate by sex, gender, and in racial/ethnic and other groups that have been marginalized and communities with low socioeconomic status should at least be equal to that of the general population.
    Action strategies (Table 2) to increase early defibrillation focus on improving AED awareness and competency, removing barriers to immediate access and retrieval during an emergency, and supporting the implementation and study of innovative technologies and strategies for early defibrillation in OHCA. Although there might be some overlap, the strategies for improving access to early defibrillation for OHCA will differ for public and residential settings (where most OHCA occur). To make substantial improvements in early defibrillation for those who experience OHCA in a residential setting, a rethinking of the public access defibrillation model is required and may require specific targets and strategies. Innovative technology facilitating the development of lightweight, compact, consumer-grade AEDs could support a new paradigm of personal access defibrillation, whereby devices are easily and regularly carried like cell phones or worn like watches. New vectors of AED delivery, including AED-equipped community volunteers dispatched in parallel with professional responders and unmanned aerial vehicles equipped with AEDs, offer new approaches requiring evaluation.110, 111
    From 2000 to 2010, there was notable improvement in survival rates for both IHCA and OHCA. For IHCA, risk-adjusted rates of survival to discharge increased from 13.7% to 22.3%, with parallel improvements in survival for shockable cardiac arrest rhythms (<30% in 2000 to ≈40% in 2010) and nonshockable cardiac arrest rhythms (7%–10% in 2010–2011 to 11–13% in 2009–2010).112 A similar pattern was observed for OHCA, with overall rates of survival to discharge increasing from 5.7% in 2005 to 2006 to 8.3% in 2012, with parallel improvements in both rhythm types. More recently, IHCA survival has improved to approximately 24% in 2016 to 2019, and OHCA survival has improved to approximately 10%.113
    A unique challenge that has emerged is the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on cardiac arrest response and survival outcomes. Initial analyses from the CARES and Get With the Guidelines-Resuscitation (GWTG-R) registries have detected dramatic decreases in OHCA and IHCA survival.6, 114, 115 It will be critical to reassess the 2030 survival targets we have laid out in this document on the basis of whether survival rates rebound to prepandemic levels in the near future.
    It is important to note that most efforts at improving cardiac arrest survival have focused on acute resuscitation management, whether inside or outside the hospital. GWTG-R has developed an awards recognition infrastructure to elevate hospitals with superior process-of-care adherence when the patient is pulseless, whether it is timely defibrillation for shockable arrest rhythms or timely administration of epinephrine for nonshockable arrest rhythms.116
    For OHCA, efforts focused on increasing rates of BCPR, EMS response time, and widespread deployment of AEDs has made, and will continue to make, substantial inroads in improving acute resuscitation response and ultimately survival.117 Yet, additional work on identifying best practices in post-resuscitation care will be critical, especially as research about early-percutaeous interverntions, extracorporeal cardiopulmonary resuscitation, targeted temperature management and fever avoidance and other strategies evolves.118 Moreover, a recognition program for high-performing EMS agencies with the highest rates of survival to hospital admission in an entity such as CARES may catalyze innovations and quality improvement in prehospital care. Finally, identifying best practices at top-performing EMS agencies that care for predominantly Black or Latinx residents for OHCA and hospitals that care for predominantly Black or Latinx patients for IHCA, as well as how these sites overcame barriers unique to these communities, is a health equity priority to begin narrowing the racial gap in survival outcomes.
    As there is variability in CPR training, provision, and outcomes by sex/gender, there is an important need to focus on strategies to address inequities in this realm.46, 47
    Prior work has primarily focused on survival and neurologic outcomes as important outcomes but this falls short of patient, family members, and clinicians’ expectations for functional outcomes and longer term outcomes beyond hospital discharge. There are existing reporting recommendations (e.g. COSCA initiative (Core Outcome Set After Cardiac Arrest) and P-COSCA initiative (Pediatric COSCA) which could be required for reporting trials outcomes which could further support how data from clinical trials are incorporated in future impact goals.119, 120 An important focus for 2030 will be having uniformly reported data from clinical trials, registeries, and infrastructure to collect and track longer term outcomes for cardiac arrest survivors with a focus on survivorship, quality of life, and physical and psychosocial wellbeing.
    The ECC Committee 2030 Target Priority is to increase survival to hospital discharge with good neurologic outcome (Cerebral Performance Category 1 or 2) after OHCA in a residential or public setting: In adults: Greater than 12% (2020 CARES: 7.1%)In children less than 1 year of age: To 6% following an initial arrest at home/residence (2020 CARES: 5.3%) and to 12% in public setting (2020 CARES: 10.9%)In children 1 to 12 years of age: To 11.5% following an initial arrest at home/residence (2020 CARES: 10.5%) and to 21% in public setting (2020 CARES: 19.2%)In children 13 to 18 years of age: To 17.5% following an initial arrest at home/residence (2020 CARES: 16%) and to 33% in public setting (2020 CARES: 30%)
    In adults: Greater than 12% (2020 CARES: 7.1%)
    In children less than 1 year of age: To 6% following an initial arrest at home/residence (2020 CARES: 5.3%) and to 12% in public setting (2020 CARES: 10.9%)
    In children 1 to 12 years of age: To 11.5% following an initial arrest at home/residence (2020 CARES: 10.5%) and to 21% in public setting (2020 CARES: 19.2%)
    In children 13 to 18 years of age: To 17.5% following an initial arrest at home/residence (2020 CARES: 16%) and to 33% in public setting (2020 CARES: 30%)
    The ECC Committee 2030 Target Priority is to increase survival to hospital discharge and survival with good neurologic outcomes (Cerebral Performance Category 1 or 2) after IHCA: In adults: Greater than 24% (2020 GWTG-R: 16%)In children: Greater than 45% (2015–2019 GWTG-R: 34%–42%)
    In adults: Greater than 24% (2020 GWTG-R: 16%)
    In children: Greater than 45% (2015–2019 GWTG-R: 34%–42%)
    The ECC Committee 2030 goal rate by sex, gender, and in racial/ethnic and other groups that have been marginalized and communities with low socioeconomic status should at least be equal to that of the general population.
    Action strategies to address improving survival after cardiac arrest (Table 2) can be centered around approaches to detect decompensating patients early, improved data collection and registries to add to our current understanding of risks and outcomes, and optimal post–cardiac arrest care and focus on survivorship and quality of life beyond hospital discharge. Early detection of clinical decompensation with early warning scores in the inpatient setting could theoretically improve outcomes, although thus far, data have been inconclusive. The many different scoring systems use different definitions of endpoints, use different algorithms of data analysis, and have undergone different validation, which make comparing scores and implementing processes challenging.121–123 In both the inpatient and out-of-hospital setting, process optimization (decreasing time to defibrillation/epinephrine administration, increasing BCPR rates, expanding public access AEDs) are all integral to improving future survival.
    Also, by identifying hospital systems, EMS agencies, and communities that achieve excellent outcomes, subsequent qualitative investigation can begin to understand how their outcomes differ.124, 125 All of this work will be incumbent upon increased funding and resource allocation at multiple levels for resuscitation science.
    The key to quality improvement is measurement, tracking, and the ability to assess how specific interventions impact health outcomes. There are 2 main registries: CARES.126 and GWTG-R.127 CARES is primarily used to capture dispatcher, prehospital, and hospital data on OHCA, whereas GWTG-R is primarily for IHCA, and the participants can access their own data and benchmark for quality improvement purposes. CARES releases a summary annual report, while GWTG-R data is primarily shared through periodic research publications, an annual report of each hospital’s risk-standardized survival rate for IHCA, and an awards program for benchmarking resuscitation processes-of-care. The 2020 CARES data included 1741 EMS agencies and 1962 hospitals with a catchment area representing approximately 44% of the US population (143.5 million people). In 2020, 127 376 treated OHCAs were included with a crude incidence of 88.8 treated arrests per 100 000 population. Unpublished CARES data on cardiac arrest differences by age, race, ethnicity, and gender are shared in Tables 3,4 (personal communication with Dr. Bryan McNally, Principal Investigator for CARES).
    The biggest challenge in achieving the AHA’s 2030 goals is that nationally representative data are either incomplete or not publicly available at the national, state, and local levels. The specific metrics for tracking cardiac arrest process and outcome measures should also be iterative evolve as new data becomes available. Reports that are publicly available currently lack adequate granularity on analyses for purposes of health equity, especially as they pertain to geographic location and neighborhood-level characteristics. The ability to access this data at a community level will be key in planning and implementing interventions where they are most likely to have the highest impact.
    Major advances in cardiac arrest research are often driven by data. Results from clinical trials often drive major advances in cardiac arrest care and outcomes. Inconsistencies exist however in how data are reported from these studies limiting sometimes their comparability or generalizability. There are existing reporting recommendations (e.g. COSCA and P-COSCA initiative) which should be required for reporting trials outcomes which could further support how data from clinical trials are incorporated in future impact goals.119, 120
    A barrier to expansion of both CARES and GWTG-R is the lack of funding, because the registries are voluntary and supported by philanthropic sources (eg, AHA) or by subscription fees by the participating agencies, states, or hospital systems. A more stable funding stream to cover costs for participating sites and statistical support will be essential to the continued success of capturing and providing feedback data for both OHCA and IHCA.
    In addition to increasing enrollment, the current measures in these registries should be expanded to allow for tracking and measurement of aspirational ares of focus and targets (Table 2) or complementary registries should be resourced and emerge which allow for tracking these measures to achieve an optimized resuscitation ecosystem in the near future. Another barrier is that reporting on cardiac arrest incidence, process measures, and outcomes is not mandatory or incentivized. If cardiac arrest were classified as a reportable disease (eg, by the Council of State and Territorial Epidemiologists), uniform reporting by all states would be mandated. Alternatively, data collection and reporting could be incentivized by linking it to healthcare system certifications or reimbursement.
    Collaboration across key stakeholder groups is also paramount to the success of this initiative. The Chain of Survival is uniquely dependent on multiple links which require coordinated efforts from the community, dispatchers, prehospital providers, healthcare systems, patients, and their caregivers to improve outcomes following cardiac arrest.
    The action strategies outlined in Table 2 address the current barriers to measurement and tracking of OHCA process measures, outcomes, and equity. These strategies require engagement and resources at the national, state, and local government levels as well as participation of all stakeholders in the local systems of care, including providers, patients, and their families.
    While this document applies to the population at large, including children, there are some differences that warrant highlighting for the pediatric population. There are disparities in treatment and outcomes for children experiencing cardiac arrest.67, 108, 128, 129 Naim et al. reported that BCPR was provided to 46.5% of pediatric OHCA arrests and that 82.6% of pediatric OHCA did not have an AED placed, which is surprisingly comparable to adult OHCA data.130 Children who are the recipients of BCPR and who have placement of an AED in OHCA are far more likely to be White and from higher-educated, higher income-earned neighborhoods.108, 129, 130 Survival, however, does not seem to be different between races both in IHCA and OHCA.67, 131 These investigators have hypothesized that this may be due to both the expansion of pediatric insurance coverage and the broad reach of major academic hospitals in caring for pediatric patients. Importantly, however, much of the differences in pediatrics stems from the predominance of a respiratory etiology of cardiac arrest. An alternative approach of compression-only CPR, offered as an educational opportunity to the public response to OHCA, has not been shown to be as effective as conventional compressions with breaths in pediatric patients.124, 130 This likely is due to the respiratory etiology in pediatric arrests and the need for rescue breaths. As shown in the improved survival section above, a large component of pediatric arrests occur in infants, at home, and are unwitnessed—likely associated with sudden infant death syndrome.124 A different approach is needed to improve these outcomes, with focus on prevention of the known risk factors and further discovery of that which is unknown as well as education and training in conventional CPR for young families and those who care for young children. A continued focus on rigorous data to guide pediatric resuscitation practices for OHCA and IHCA would also be beneficial.

    Conclusion

    These goals for 2030 were developed while we exist in a truly extraordinary time.
    The context of the world surrounding the experts during the deliberations for this manuscript includes a worldwide pandemic already responsible for more than 5.5 million deaths (as of January 2022), substantial economic stress throughout major segments of the business world, cultures struggling to come to terms with racism and inequality, and the expectation that climate change will soon emerge as the largest global threat to human health, along with acutely worsening metrics on cardiovascular health and diminished survival rates in nearly every community.
    The authors debated all these issues fiercely in an attempt to provide goals that balanced the need to improve cardiovascular health and survival rates against the many ongoing additional pressing issues faced by our communities during a stressful period in our history. These 2030 goals attempt to reflect our optimism for improvement that is based in a pragmatic foundation of what is realistic given where we are today.
    These 2030 goals serve as an achievable road map for improved cardiovascular health and better survival rates in all communities. The themes presented harmonize with the new goals of the AHA to create a world where every person can lead a full healthy life and reflect our ongoing struggles to contain the COVID-19 pandemic. There is an increasing recognition of the need for more equitable care, the need to identify disparities and structural inequity, and to create better systems of care that will remove the ongoing unfair systems that perpetuate these disparities. New proposed metrics will allow us to document our progress in resolving disparities. We seek to extend the impact of the interventions that we know to be effective. Improving the rates of BCPR and advancing the coverage of AEDs to provide more rapid defibrillation serve as a foundation. Collecting critical data on important metrics like rates of BCPR, use of AEDs, and survival rates allow us to delve into the issues of disparities while improving care for everyone.
    Working toward these 2030 goals will advance our response to cardiac arrest. It will engage all our communities in promoting better public health so that we actually care for one another, and it will advance us to where all people can look forward to leading the fullest and most healthy life possible.
    CS

    Dr. Comilla Sasson

    Emergency Medicine · General Emergency Medicine
    University of Colorado Anschutz
    comilla