Description of Cryptococcosis Following SARS-CoV-2 Infection: A Disease Survey Through the Mycosis Study Group Education and Research Consortium (MSG-19).
Feb 17, 2024DOI: 10.1093/cid/ciad551Journal ArticleCID
Written by: Jeremey WalkerTodd McCartyGerald McGwinEloy E OrdayaPaschalis VergidisLuis Ostrosky-ZeichnerMehriban MammadovaAndrej SpecAdriana M RauseoJohn PerfectJulia MessinaGabriel VilchezRachel McMullenCarolynn T JonesPeter G PappasMycoses Study Group Education and Research Consortium (MSGERC) Cryptococcal Registry Cohort
We designed a crowdsourced case survey registry of patients with cryptococcal infection within 90 days of infection with SARS-CoV-2. We accepted case patients who were diagnosed between 1 March 2020 and 31 March 2022.To be eligible for this survey, the cryptococcal infection must have occurred within 90 days of documented SARS-CoV-2 infection. Cryptococcal infection was defined as a positive serum and/or cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) cryptococcal antigen (CrAg) or a positive culture for Cryptococcus spp from any site. We limited our cases in this series to adults >18 years of age. We categorized cryptococcal infection as follows: CNS disease, disseminated cryptococcosis (proven/probable), and respiratory disease alone. The definition for CNS disease required either positive CSF culture or positive CSF CrAg. Disseminated cryptococcosis was defined based on serum and blood studies. Proven disseminated cryptococcosis required positive blood cultures for Cryptococcus spp, whereas probable disease was defined by positive serum CrAg with negative blood cultures. If a patient had CNS disease, they were classified as this regardless of other cultures. If patient had positive blood cultures or serum antigen without CNS involvement, then they were classified as having proven or probable disseminated disease. Respiratory cultures only were cases in whom diagnosis was made by positive respiratory cultures without any additional positive cultures or antigen results. Immunocompromised individuals were defined as those with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), solid organ transplant (SOT), active malignancy on treatment, or chronic immunosuppressive medications.The registry was developed to collect basic demographic information (age, sex, geographic region), known risk factors for cryptococcosis (immunocompromised states, diabetes, prior cryptococcal infection), description of SARS-CoV-2 infection (method of diagnosis, year of infection, hospitalization, therapies provided), and cryptococcosis disease (results of diagnostic tests, signs and symptoms of cryptococcosis, days between SARS-CoV-2 infection and cryptococcal infection, treatment, and 6-month outcomes). Contact details of site investigators were included to allow follow-up and clarification of all entries. All case data were to be collected through a secure REDCap database, and no identifiable protected health information was requested (Supplementary File 1). The University of Alabama at Birmingham institutional review board (IRB) determined that the registry was exempt from full review. Some participating sites were able to use our IRB exemption; others had policies requiring independent IRB submissions at the local sites before participating.After responding to the call for cases meeting study-prespecified definitions, providers were emailed a web link to the study REDCap electronic data capture tools hosted at the University of Alabama at Birmingham [11, 12]. The survey instrument included contact information for the recording provider for the purpose of resolving missing or unclear data through direct email. Providers would complete a separate survey for each case they had identified. Our survey responses were collected from 11 February 2022 through May 31 2022.We used several means to disseminate information about the availability of the survey. First, the MSGERC released a call for cases of cryptococcosis following SARS-CoV-2 infection through an independent listserv. We also disseminated the survey through the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Emerging Infectious Diseases Network. Finally, we disseminated information about the survey through the Twitter infectious diseases community. Providers who were interested in participating were sent a direct email that included the REDCap survey web link. Four investigators (E. E. O., M. M., A. M. R., D. O.) identified cases from their institutions through locally approved searches of institutional EMR data to identify potential cases and then retrospectively reviewed the EMR to ensure they met inclusion criteria. This accounts for 26 of our total cases. Twelve additional cases were contributed by 2 centers (University of Alabama at Birmingham and Duke University) and reflect the collective of cases recognized by clinical faculty at those institutions. The remaining 31 cases were submitted by individual responses to the distributed survey.Data from the registry REDCap database were analyzed using descriptive statistics. The χ2 test was used to compare groups, including host immune factors and mortality.
RESULTS
Sixty-nine cases were identified and submitted from 29 separate sites. Individual providers from 6 sites contributed a range of 4–9 cases each. Providers from the remaining sites contributed a range of 1–3 cases each. The majority of cases were reported from United States sites (Table 1). Median age of cases was 61 years and 68% were male; 36 (52%) cases had no significant immunocompromising condition. SARS-CoV-2 infection was documented across the time from pandemic onset in early 2020 through 2022. Fifty-six cases received some directed treatment for COVID-19 including 39 (57%) receiving antivirals, 15 (22%) antibody, and 51 (74%) additional immunosuppressants. The immunosuppressants used included glucocorticosteroids (n = 50), interleukin 6 inhibitor (IL-6; n = 7), and Janus kinase inhibitor (n = 5). Thirteen cases did not require hospitalization for SARS-CoV-2 infection and, of that group, only 2 received additional immunosuppressants as outpatient, both of which were glucocorticosteroids. Seven of the 13 cases not hospitalized for SARS-CoV-2 were immunocompromised due to active malignancy (n = 4), chronic immunosuppressants (n = 1), HIV (n = 1), and SOT (n = 1).Patient Characteristics (N = 69)Data are presented as No. (%) unless otherwise indicated.Abbreviations: COVID-19, coronavirus disease 2019; HIV, human immunodeficiency virus; IL-6, interleukin 6; IQR, interquartile range; JAK, Janus kinase; mTOR, mammalian target of rapamycin.Cryptococcosis was diagnosed a median of 22 days (interquartile range, 9–42 days) after SARS-CoV-2 infection (Table 2). The symptoms were broad and overlapped with SARS-CoV-2 symptoms including cough (n = 30), fever (n = 26), confusion (n = 20), and lethargy (n = 18). Eleven cases of cryptococcal infection were diagnosed postmortem, primarily through blood or respiratory cultures. Evaluation for cryptococcal infection included blood cultures in 63 (91%), serum CrAg in 54 (78%), and CSF evaluation in 33 (47%). The site of infection was confirmed to be CNS cryptococcosis in 13 (19%), proven disseminated disease in 22 (32%), probable disseminated disease in 18 (26%), and respiratory disease only in 16 (23%) (Table 3). All of the 16 with respiratory disease had some evaluation for disseminated Cryptococcus, 11 by serum CrAg testing and the remaining 5 with blood cultures (Supplementary File 2 includes available testing information for all patients). Amphotericin B was used for induction therapy in 39 cases (57%). Of those 30 cases without amphotericin B induction, the reasons cited were diagnosis made postmortem (n = 11), disease severity did not warrant the use of this drug (n = 10), unknown reason (n = 4), drug not available (n = 3), and concerns for toxicity (n = 2).Cryptococcosis Following Coronavirus Disease 2019Data are presented as No. (%) unless otherwise indicated.Abbreviations: BAL, bronchoalveolar lavage; COVID-19, coronavirus disease 2019; CrAg, cryptococcal antigen; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; IQR, interquartile range.aDiagnosis confirmed on the basis of data that were returned postmortem (n = 11).Location of Cryptococcal Disease Diagnosis, Host Factors, and OutcomesAbbreviation: CNS, central nervous system.Outcomes at 6 months were available in 67 of 69 patients (97%). Within that group, 41 (61%) patients had died within 6 months, representing 59% of our total population. Both patients for whom outcomes were unavailable were lost to follow-up. Mortality among those with available follow-up was 72% (26/36) for the immunocompetent group and 48% (15/31) for the immunocompromised group (likelihood ratio, 4; P = .046). Mortality outcomes were also higher for those hospitalized for SARS-CoV-2 (P < .001) and those with certain cryptococcal disease presentations (P = .002). Specifically, those with proven disseminated cryptococcosis and pulmonary cryptococcosis had the highest all-cause mortality at 95% (19/20) and 56% (9/16), respectively. By comparison, those with probable disseminated disease and CNS disease had all-cause mortality of 44% (8/18) and 38% (5/13), respectively. Disease category at time of diagnosis was also related to immunocompromised status, with immunocompromised patients having more frequent CNS disease (27% [9/33]) and probable disseminated disease (36% [12/33]), while immunocompetent patients were more likely to be diagnosed by positive blood culture (36% [13/36]) and respiratory culture (36% [13/36]). Among 13 patients with CNS disease, complications included cerebrovascular accident in 3, permanent shunting due to persistently elevated opening pressure in 2, and immune reconstitution–like syndrome in 2.We observed a few unusual presentations of Cryptococcus among these subjects that should be highlighted. Two patients had recurrent cryptococcal infection. One patient had a history of heart transplant and CNS cryptococcosis 9 years previously and had completed therapy 7 years prior to diagnosis of COVID-19. The patient had minimally symptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infection managed with supportive care only, and subsequently presented with recurrent CNS cryptococcal disease including positive blood and CSF cultures. This patient responded to reinduction antifungal therapy with amphotericin B and flucytosine, then transitioned to lifelong suppressive fluconazole. Another patient had uncontrolled HIV and CNS cryptococcal infection 2 years prior to COVID-19 diagnosis and was no longer receiving antiretroviral or antifungal therapy when they presented with symptoms of cryptococcal CNS infection and consistent CrAg results. Finally, a patient with rheumatoid arthritis on chronic immunosuppressive medications had positive blood cultures for C. neoformans but simultaneously had negative serum CrAg, suggesting a prozone phenomenon or less likely an acapsular strain.
DISCUSSION
Invasive mycoses associated with severe SARS-CoV-2 infections are being increasingly recognized, especially pulmonary aspergillosis and invasive candidiasis. Herein we report the characteristics of subjects who developed CNS, disseminated, or respiratory cryptococcosis shortly following SARS-CoV-2 infection. There have been numerous case reports and small reviews describing cryptococcal infection following COVID-19 [8, 10, 13–15]. In this series of 69 cases from 29 centers, we attempt to better describe the characteristics of this population including disease manifestations, underlying comorbidities, treatment, and outcome. The largest series to date described 65 patients who were identified via International Classification of Diseases, Tenth Revision (ICD-10) codes from anonymous data captured through a federated research network [9]. This series was notable for high rates of HIV (32%), organ transplant (28%), and immunodeficiency (47%) which, alongside other autoimmune disease, diabetes, and end-organ failure, were all found to be risk factors for cryptococcosis when compared to other patients identified in their system with COVID-19 [9]. Our disease survey adds significant detail to this body of literature as each case was confirmed by both standardized testing and individualized provider review. Additionally, our cohort includes more patients traditionally considered immunocompetent and demonstrates an overall high mortality.In immunocompromised states such as SOT, cryptococcosis is generally seen as a reactivation of quiescent disease residing in lungs, which may disseminate into bloodstream and the CNS. This fact and the low baseline incidence of infection make it challenging to establish a causal association between SARS-CoV-2 and cryptococcal diagnosis. Our series identified a few groups of individuals that provide important clues to this disease phenomenon.We identified 11 cases postmortem through blood (n = 7) and respiratory cultures (n = 4). The median time between diagnosis of SARS-CoV-2 infection and cryptococcosis was 22 days (range, 5–42 days). Nine of these patients were immunocompetent preceding SARS-CoV-2 infection, all were hospitalized for COVID-19 treatment, and most received immunosuppressive medications for COVID-19 (6 received glucocorticoids and 1 received both glucocorticoids and an IL-6 inhibitor). Overall, there were 36 immunocompetent individuals who most commonly manifested disease through positive cultures either from respiratory system or blood. This pattern fits with our known epidemiology of cryptococcosis, and the rapid blood dissemination suggests a profoundly immunosuppressed state as has been described in critical illness with COVID-19 [3]. The immunocompetent group had a very high mortality at 72%, significantly higher than the 48% mortality observed in immunocompromised patients, with likelihood ratio of 4. A trend toward higher mortality in immunocompetent individuals was also suggested in a prior study [16]. Overall mortality among patients with respiratory disease alone was >56%, significantly higher than reported in any modern case series, where pulmonary cryptococcosis is consistently associated with lower mortality risks, usually <10% [16]. Further exploration is required to describe this phenomenon, but we suspect the profound lung injury and immunodeficiency seen with severe SARS-CoV-2 infection could predispose to rapid quiescent reactivation with organism burden sufficient for culture-proven disease. Although the retrospective nature of this study limited testing, 69% defined with respiratory disease did have negative serum CrAg testing. We can only speculate about the impact of pulmonary cryptococcal infection on overall mortality in our series, but at a minimum it appears to be a prognostic marker in hospitalized patients with SARS-CoV-2.We identified 13 cases with CNS cryptococcosis, which is typically considered the latest stage and the most severe disease manifestation. This was seen more commonly in patients with immunosuppressed conditions (69%) but not necessarily severe COVID-19. Indeed, 31% did not require hospitalization for COVID-19 and 24% were managed with supportive care only. The development of this severe manifestation in absence of critical illness (defined as hospitalization) and without additional immunosuppressants suggests some direct impact from viral illness on the immune system. Although this group of patients with CNS disease had lower mortality in our series than other disease sites, it remains high compared to literature with mortality rate at 38%. The overlap of symptoms for COVID-19 and Cryptococcus are difficult to distinguish and a few cases described a diagnostic delay due to symptoms such as headache, nausea, and fatigue being attributed to “long COVID.” Thus it is important to consider cryptococcal disease including meningitis in the 3- to 6-week period following SARS-CoV-2 infection, particularly in those with additional risk factors such as immunocompromised states.The most compelling case example to suggest a causative relationship between viral infection and subsequent cryptococcal disease was from a heart transplant recipient with recurrent cryptococcal disease. This patient had completed cryptococcal treatment >7 years prior without recurrence. The patient's SARS-CoV-2 infection was mild, and the patient was managed as an outpatient without any change in baseline immunosuppressants (sirolimus and tacrolimus) or additional therapy. At time of cryptococcal diagnosis, both CNS and blood cultures were positive. This case provides support toward an additional risk to infection following viral infection, although further study is required to confirm and define the level of risk and understand how it varies based on presentation of viral infection from SARS-CoV-2. For example, the predisposition for pulmonary mold infections is well described in influenza [3, 17], but Cryptococcus has been described only in a few reports [7, 8, 18].Many studies looking at concurrent infections with SARS-CoV-2, particularly in immunocompromised persons such as SOT recipients, have focused on nosocomial infections and short-term outcomes with average follow-up <1 month [5, 6]. The prior series utilizing ICD-10 codes found that most cases occurred within 10 days, but we found a longer delay with median of 22 days between diagnosis, and 25 cases (36%) had diagnosis confirmed after 30 days. This difference could be related to our methodology, as physician case surveys would be more likely to link outpatient SARS-CoV-2 infections to inpatient cryptococcal infections. In addition to later presentations, we also observed diagnostic delays with 19 (28%) of our cases having symptoms of cryptococcal disease for ≥14 days prior to diagnosis of fungal infection. This delay has been described frequently in cryptococcal disease along with more severe disease manifestations and complications [2, 16]. Thus, our data suggest a need for assessment of opportunistic infections beyond 30 days for patients with SARS-CoV-2 infection, especially in subsequent studies.This report is limited to retrospective data collection entered as a survey by medical providers and thus some data points are incomplete due to these tests not being completed or unavailable. We did require documentation of laboratory confirmation for both diagnoses to ensure case confirmation. Although this approach prevents us from being able to review other EMR data not included in our survey (Supplementary File 1), it did allow us to expand reach to 29 centers. Although we utilized listservs with global contacts for our “call for cases,” we only had 3 cases submitted from outside the United States. Given that Cryptococcus is a cosmopolitan organism, it would be expected that this limitation speaks to the reach of the professional networks utilized rather than a geographic predisposition, although this cannot be stated with certainty. As our case series is heterogenous including many types of immunosuppression, as well as patients not traditionally considered immunosuppressed, we are unable to provide a sufficient comparator group and thus we are limited to case description rather than identifying causation. Finally, the retrospective design of the study may promote recruitment of memorable cases, which could contribute to the higher mortality observed. However, more than half of our cases represented a broader institutional experience rather than individual anecdote and higher mortality has been demonstrated in other descriptions of invasive fungal infections following severe respiratory illness including SARS-CoV-2 [9, 18, 19]. The strengths of our study include the number of cases and complexity of information regarding risk factors, disease manifestations, and outcomes.This case series highlights a temporal relationship between SARS-CoV-2 and cryptococcosis and reveals a concerning mortality rate of 59% in our overall population that is significantly higher than other cryptococcal infection case series in the modern era. Although a theoretical framework exists to explain this association, it has not been previously described in this amount of detail. Notably, several of our cases were delayed in diagnosis, in part due to attributions of symptoms to long-term effects of COVID-19. This demonstrates the need for careful consideration for clinicians when caring for this population.
Supplementary Data
Supplementary materials are available at Clinical Infectious Diseases online. Consisting of data provided by the authors to benefit the reader, the posted materials are not copyedited and are the sole responsibility of the authors, so questions or comments should be addressed to the corresponding author.
Supplementary Material
Click here for additional data file.
GV
Dr. Gabriel Vilchez
Infectious Disease · General Infectious DiseaseBluegrass ID Associatesgabrielv