Approximately 85% of the population demonstrate right coronary dominance, 8% demonstrate left coronary dominance, and the remaining 7% demonstrate variation of codominance.5 Racial and sex differences in coronary dominance have been described indicating possible genetic drivers of coronary anatomy. Ihdayhid et al observed significant differences in the frequency of coronary dominance in 3 populations—East Asian, South Asian, and European—undergoing coronary computed tomography angiogram with 96%, 87%, and 87% individuals with right coronary dominance in those groups, respectively.6 Other population cohorts have demonstrated variations in coronary dominance frequency, possibly due to ethnic differences. For example, Ramanathan et al described a right coronary dominance of 54% in a population of 300 South Indian patients undergoing coronary angiography for chest pain evaluation,7 while Claudino Dos Santos et al observed a right, left, and codominance pattern of 53%, 44%, and 4% respectively, in northern Brazilian autopsy cases in 57 patients without obvious cardiac injury.8 Differences in coronary dominance patterns based on sex have also been described. In a large observational sample of 207 926 patients receiving coronary angiogram for assessment of acute coronary syndrome (ACS) in the National Cardiovascular Data Registry Cath Percutaneous Coronary Intervention cohort, Parikh et al observed significantly higher prevalence of right coronary dominance in women.9 In smaller studies with similar populations, Kuno et al10 and Goldberg et al11 demonstrate a similar but nonsignificant trend with prevalence of 91.5% and 92.6% of right dominance in women compared with 90.2% and 91.5% in men, respectively, between the 2 studies. These observations of coronary dominance have been studied predominantly in the context of particular clinical cohorts of various cardiac diseases or cohorts undergoing cardiac testing. Therefore, currently available prevalence estimates may introduce ascertainment biases, and the true prevalence of various dominance patterns in the overall population remains uncertain. Furthermore, differences have not been investigated in the context of other mechanisms affected by racial and sex differences such as coronary dysregulation; and it is not clear to what extent racial and sex differences may affect the relationship between coronary dominance differences and the development of heart disease.12, 13
Embryology of Cardiac Dominance
The coronary arterial tree develops between weeks 6 and 8 of gestation in human embryos.14 The angiogenesis process begins as immature epicardial plexuses are formed by the proepicardium and the sinus venosus region,15 undergoing morphogenesis and branching to cover the entire myocardium.14 The pluripotent cells subsequently invade the myocardium to develop small vessels and capillaries.16 Serial sections of both human and rat embryos have shown that the small vessels on the surface of the heart fuse and grow inward toward the aorta as buds form to develop into the coronary cusps.15, 17 The left aortic bud forms the left coronary cusp and anastomosis with the left main coronary artery before the right cusp joins with the RCA.18
Although the embryologic process by which coronary dominance is established has not been clearly elucidated, there are several possible factors that may influence the coronary dominance pattern. While no specific genetic patterns to coronary dominance have been identified in humans, murine models support dominance pattern as a breedable trait.19 One area of embryologic insight stems from observational data of patients with congenital heart defects. In patients with a tetralogy of Fallot, specific morphological defects including rightward and antero‐cephalad deviation of the conotruncal septum demonstrate a greater incidence of the right dominance pattern.16, 20 This finding suggests coronary dominance may be influenced by the typical rotation of the developing heart, though case reports of patients with dextrocardia do not reveal an impact on coronary dominance pattern.
Additionally, it has been postulated that hemodynamic differences may influence the development of coronary dominance. Evidence suggests that increased left‐sided cardiac oxygen demand drives the expansion of the RCA tree to perfuse the left‐sided myocardium.21 This theory is supported by findings of lower frequency of right coronary dominance in patients with reduced left cardiac workload and oxygen demand in the developing heart, such as in the case of hypoplastic left heart syndrome.22, 23 Other structural abnormalities such as bicuspid aortic disease also appear to have a higher prevalence of left coronary dominance,4, 24 although whether these abnormalities directly impact the development of coronary dominance or share a common confounding risk factor is not established.
Difference in Coronary Flow of Left and Right Dominant Coronary Systems
There are differences in flow rate and pattern between coronary dominance systems. Although the total coronary blood flow between anatomic variants is comparable,25 the proportion of total flow through the left system has much higher variance and is dependent on dominance in both the developing26 and fully developed6, 27, 28, 29, 30 hearts.
Direct measurements of coronary arterial flow suggests differences in distribution of average and peak coronary flow velocity between right‐ and left‐dominant systems.25, 31 Classic right coronary dominance demonstrates a pattern of coronary flow where perfusion of the left ventricle occurs predominantly in diastole; this includes flow of the distal RCA as it perfuses the inferior aspect of the left ventricle.32 In contrast, coronary perfusion of the mid‐RCA territories tends to peak during systole.33 This may be attributable to a relatively small change of the net driving pressure within the right coronary system compared with that of the left, particularly in the left anterior descending artery (LAD) with a resultant decrease in wave intensity within the left coronary system,34 although other features of coronary flow regulation may also be impacted. Notably, during periods of increased cardiac work and coronary blood flow demand, the right system preferentially increases perfusion in systole, whereas the left system is more dependent on augmentation of diastolic flow.35 This is possibly exacerbated by differences in myocardial strain patterns, with higher regional and global strain patterns in those with right and co‐coronary dominance compared with left, particularly on the longitudinal and circumferential planes.36 Ventricular coronary flow within the RCA is also sensitive to elevated right ventricular pressures, where elevated pulmonary artery pressures may lead to compromise of systolic perfusion and reduced diastolic perfusion.37
Shear forces within coronary arteries contribute to microvascular injury, which can have hemodynamic consequences. In fluid dynamics, shear force on a thin wall may be influenced by total flow, angle of offtake, and rate of diameter change.38, 39, 40 In left‐dominant systems, >90% of the coronary blood flow enters the left coronary artery, which can cause high shear stress at the bifurcation of the left main artery.41, 42 The PDA, a significant anatomic variation defining coronary dominance, exhibits a greater angle of takeoff in left‐dominant hearts compared with right‐dominant systems.43, 44 Overall, coronary artery lumen sizes were observed to be larger within the respective dominant coronary system, with differences more pronounced within distal branches.45, 46 Differences in venous morphology between the various coronary dominance systems have also been described,47 which may impact the net forces driving coronary blood flow.48 These factors may impact overall coronary flow patterns, induce turbulent flow, and contribute to differences in shear force experienced by the coronary wall of the left and right arterial system and contribute to differences in atherosclerotic development and clinical outcomes.49, 50 Alternative modalities of imaging may provide clarity of the underlying mechanism driving these observed differences of coronary flow behavior as it relates to coronary dominance.12, 13
Cardiac Tissue Perfusion in Various Cardiac Dominance Patterns
Differences in coronary dominance lead to variation in tissue perfusion pattern of the myocardium. In patients with right coronary dominance, Feinstein et al51 observed that the RCA was the major contributor to the inferior and inferoseptal perfusion in 89%, midseptal in 17%, and posteromedial papillary in 42% of cases. In contrast, patients with left‐dominant systems had inferior and inferoseptal regions supplied by left and right systems equally in half of cases, and both the anterolateral and posteromedial papillary were more likely to be perfused by the left system. Morcerf et al revealed similar trends, with the inferior and inferoseptal region perfused by the RCA in 85% and 82% of cases of right coronary dominance and the left coronary artery in 70% and 71% cases of left coronary dominance, respectively; the posteromedial papillary muscle was perfused by the RCA in 77% cases of right coronary dominance and the left coronary artery in 86% cases of left coronary dominance.52 In both patterns, the inferolateral segment of the heart was generally perfused by the left coronary artery. In left‐dominant systems, the inferior wall was found to be spared in RCA lesions and involved in lesions of the LCx.53
Perfusion patterns demonstrate that a dominant RCA tends to perfuse a large territory of the left ventricle, while a dominant left coronary artery tends to perfuse a small territory of the right ventricle.21 The extensive branching pattern of the arteries of the right coronary system account for this discrepancy. For instance, the posterolateral left ventricular artery observed in right and co‐coronary dominance patterns54, 55, 56, 57 perfuse the posterior wall, posterior septum, and adjacent areas of both ventricles.58 Development of collaterals to the inferior heart may also be more prominent in individuals with right coronary dominance both with59 and without evidence of atherosclerotic disease,60 which may contribute to perfusion and survival benefit in patients with coronary artery disease.12 Clinically, increased periprocedural myocardial infarction in patients with left coronary dominance undergoing percutaneous coronary interventions have been observed in post hoc analysis and may be due to differences in overlapping arterial supply in left‐ compared with right‐dominant systems and reduction in flow related to stent‐induced closure of these side branches.60, 61 Conversely, in left‐dominant patterns, the LAD tends to perfuse the inferior wall by wrapping around the cardiac apex, often anastomosing with the PDA.29, 54, 62 In right coronary dominance, the left ventricular posterior wall is principally supplied by the RCA system, though in the majority of cases, distal vessels of the left arterial system provided collateral flow.63 This contrasts with the left‐dominant system, which has a single coronary arterial supply of the left posterior wall without contribution from the RCA. In these situations, the contribution of the right side is scant and may predispose the involved region to infarct.64
Though most areas of research have focused on the relationship between coronary dominance and ventricular perfusion, there is evidence of differences of the perfusion in the cardiac atria and conduction system. In sheep hearts, variations in coronary dominance led to differences of left and right coronary arterial contribution to the left atrium.65 The atrioventricular nodal artery is observed to arise from the dominant coronary artery in all cases, including codominant populations.57, 65, 66 Alternatively, the sinoatrial node is less frequently perfused by the dominant coronary artery compared to the atrioventricular node,67, 68 with some authors observing the sinoatrial nodal artery often branches from the nondominant artery.7, 69 In terms of more distal conduction system perfusion, the right bundle‐branch system is proximally supplied by both the LAD and atrioventricular nodal arteries and distally by only the LAD,70 which may have clinical implications for conduction disease.
Clinical Relevance and Disease Risk Associated With Coronary Dominance
Postmortem evaluation reveals that the prevalence of left and codominant circulation decreases with age, suggesting that left dominance may be associated with earlier death.71 In this section, we discuss the possible reasons for this finding and the association between coronary artery dominance patterns and development of disease (Tables S1 through S3).
Difference in coronary flow has been associated with greater prevalence of coronary disease in the LAD in individuals with left coronary dominance3, 9, 41 due to both increased flow volume and longer LADs in left‐dominant systems.72 Left coronary dominance has also been associated with increased prevalence of myocardial bridges particularly within the left coronary system and LAD,73, 74 possibly increasing risk for nonatherosclerotic obstructive disease. Conversely, RCA atherosclerotic disease was more prevalent in individuals with right dominance.3 Right‐dominant patients also tend to have a higher frequency of triple‐vessel disease, suggesting a more uniform development of atherosclerotic disease pattern.9 In evaluation of coronary artery calcium, increased coronary calcium in the proximal dominant artery was an independent predictor of coronary disease events.75 Moreover, the presence of significant CAD on coronary computed tomography angiogram in patients with a dominant left coronary system was associated with a poorer outcome than those with disease of a dominant RCA system,76 possibly related to an increase in the territory at risk of injury.
Functionally, left coronary dominance has been found to be an independent predictor of myocardial infarct following percutaneous revascularization and non–Q wave myocardial infarct.61 Obstructive disease in the left main coronary artery was found to be associated with worse outcomes in left dominance compared with that of right dominance.77 Beyond left main disease, left coronary dominance is also associated with poor outcomes in ACS after percutaneous coronary intervention,10, 72, 78 including with higher rates of cardiogenic shock in LCx occlusions72, 79 and a larger area of infarct.80 In a patient population of 27 289 undergoing coronary angiogram for evaluation of ACS, Goldberg et al observed lower long‐term survival with a 3.5‐year mortality rate of 20.1% in left‐dominant, 16.8% in right‐dominant, and 16.2% in codominant coronary systems, respectively.11 Patients with ST‐segment–elevation myocardial infarction with left coronary dominance also demonstrated higher risk of 30‐day all‐cause death, reinfarct, and major adverse cardiac events.81 In a meta‐analysis of 266 119 total patients, Khan et al demonstrated increased risk of all‐cause death in patients with ACS with left coronary dominance.82 Similar outcomes are observed in patients undergoing surgical coronary bypass in reference to 30‐day death, all‐cause death, and major adverse cardiac events after the procedure.83, 84 These findings suggest that identification of left‐dominant coronary circulation in patients who present with ACS may aid with risk stratification of complications such as cardiogenic shock as well as help with short‐ and long‐term prognostication.
Differences in anatomy of the cardiac conduction system perfusion due to coronary dominance are associated with risk of dysrhythmias and conduction disease. Studies in both animal models85 and humans66 have noted higher risk of atrial fibrillation in individuals with left coronary dominance possibly related to reduced perfusion reserve of the left coronary system and left atrium.
As the arterial supply of conduction pathways is dependent on coronary dominance, left and right coronary dominance patterns exhibit different likelihood of developing conduction delays and block. Patients with left coronary dominance were found to have significantly longer P waves independent of underlying heart disease,66 indicating an underlying difference in atrial conduction. Several authors also observed a propensity of left coronary dominance hearts to develop sinus node injury in both the presence86 and absence66 of identifiable CAD. Similarly, atrioventricular node dysfunction in the setting of coronary disease appears to be dependent on dominance pattern.87 Following perfusion patterns, right‐dominant systems with atrioventricular node arteries from the RCA appear to have an increased tendency to develop right bundle‐branch blocks,70 although the overall dominance pattern was noted to be similar in patients with and without right bundle‐branch blocks. The left anterior fascicle, which generally receives its blood supply from the LAD, is observed to develop conduction blocks resulting in hemiblocks more frequently in left coronary dominance in the setting of LAD obstruction.88 Clinically, lesions in the dominant artery predispose the involved heart to requiring intraprocedural cardiac pacing89 and increased rates of atrioventricular nodal blocks in patients with myocardial infarction.86 These findings support the potentially important clinical value of coronary dominance in patients with conduction disease in the setting of ACS for the risk stratification of arrhythmogenic complications. Left dominance has also been associated with higher incidence of both premature atrial and ventricular contractions, but the pathogenesis is not well established.66
Coronary dominance appears to be an independent risk factor for the development of left ventricular hypertrophy, with those of left and codominant patterns exhibiting higher rates of hypertrophy, particularly in women.90 Unequal hypertrophy patterns between left and right may also be represented in the QRS axis between the 2 groups such that left coronary dominance tends to deviate more leftward.91
Valvular disease and complications related to valvular procedures also appear to be associated with coronary dominance. Patients with left coronary dominance were observed to have increased rates of aortic stenosis in patients with both tricuspid and bicuspid aortic valves.92, 93 Alternatively, neither mitral prolapse nor ischemic mitral regurgitation were found to be dependent on coronary dominance in the setting of ACS.65, 94
Coronary artery dominance may have implications on surgical and percutaneous interventions, particularly interventions involving the mitral valve. The LCx of a patient with left coronary dominance was observed to be closer to the mitral annulus than those in right‐dominant individuals,95 while the RCA was closer to the mitral annulus in individuals with a right coronary dominance pattern.95, 96 In patients with ischemic mitral regurgitation, Gopal et al observed a higher proximity of the coronary sinus and the LCx in patients with left coronary dominance,97 which may result in a high risk of complications in coronary sinus devices. Additionally, this anatomy has been associated with an increased risk of LCx injury in patients with left coronary dominance undergoing mitral valve surgery compared with those of right dominance.98 Preprocedural knowledge of coronary dominance may therefore be beneficial in risk analysis for complication of valvular repair, although this requires further evaluation and the role of coronary dominance in other structural procedures such as transcatheter aortic valve implantation remains unclear.99
Conclusions
This review covers the current body of literature regarding the anatomic and hemodynamic implications of coronary dominance and its clinical relevance in the context of ischemic, electrophysiologic, and structural heart disease (Figure 4). Appreciation of coronary dominance may have important implications for patient care. Due to greater morbidity among individuals with left‐dominant circulation, patients with left‐dominant circulation may warrant higher vigilance for ischemic and arrhythmic complications after common cardiac procedures. However, we identify potential gaps in our understanding of coronary dominance. Additional studies may be beneficial to broaden our understanding of the clinical implications associated with different coronary dominance patterns and to identify opportunities for more effective guidance in therapeutic decision making. For example, further studies are warranted on the potential effect of coronary dominance on the growing field of structural heart disease. Likewise, additional consideration of the role of coronary dominance on clinical propensity for right ventricular dysfunction in clinical scenarios including heart failure, left‐sided ventricular mechanical support, and pulmonary hypertension may further augment our understanding of the clinical importance of coronary dominance.
ACS indicates acute coronary syndrome; CAD, coronary artery disease; LAD, left anterior descending artery; LVH, left ventricular hypertrophy; MACE, major averse cardiac events; RBBB, right bundle‐branch block; and RCA, right coronary artery.
Disclosures
None.
Supporting information
Tables S1–S3
PP
Dr. Purvi Parwani
Cardiology · Advanced Cardiac ImagingLoma Linda Universitypurvi