Bringing doctors together

or

A free, private network for verified physicians

Leading voices

Dr. Chris Beyrer

Global Health · Duke University

View

Dr. Lance Okeke

HIV/AIDS Medicine · Duke University

View

Dr. Raphael J. Landovitz

HIV/AIDS Medicine · UCLA

View

Dr. Keith Kaye

General ID · RU

View

Dr. Helen Boucher

Transplant/Immunocompromised States · Tufts

View

Dr. Sara Dong

Transplant/Immunocompromised States · Boston Children's Hospital

View

Dr. Aniruddha Hazra

HIV/AIDS Medicine · UCMC

View

Dr. Rochelle Walensky

General ID · Harvard Medical School

View

Dr. Kelly Dooley

Mycobacterial Disease · Vanderbilt

View

Dr. Erin Bonura

General ID · OHSU

View
  • Discover your community

  • Stay current

  • A profile that represents you

  • Find your people

About RoonPrivacyTerms

    Overview

    Indication-based clinical decision support for inpatient urine testing: impacts on utilization, appropriateness, and antibiotic prescribing.

    Jul 24, 2026DOI: 10.1017/ash.2026.10805Journal ArticleASHE

    Written by: Mario Luis Valdez ImbertAllyson Larcena TipgosMajd AlsoubaniMaureen CampionRachel ErdilShira DoronGabriela Andujar VazquezKap Sum Foong

    Find these authors on Roon

    SD
    Dr. Shira Doron
    Healthcare Epidemiology · AdventHealth Orlando

    Introduction

    Inappropriate urine testing in hospitalized patients contributes to unnecessary treatment of asymptomatic bacteriuria, as cultures obtained without urinary symptoms detect colonization rather than infection, driving avoidable antimicrobial exposure.1,2 Despite national guideline recommendations against screening for and treatment of asymptomatic bacteriuria in most populations, unnecessary urine testing remains common across acute care settings.1 Reducing unnecessary urine testing is therefore an important target for diagnostic stewardship.2Diagnostic stewardship aims to optimize test ordering, processing, and interpretation to improve clinical care and antimicrobial use.2 Clinical decision support (CDS) integrated into computerized physician order entry(CPOE) has shown promise in reducing urine culture utilization.3 However, the impact of indication-based CDS on overall urine testing patterns and on documentation-supported appropriateness of test ordering and antibiotic prescribing remain unclear.In August 2024, Tufts Medicine implemented an indication-based CDS tool for inpatient urine testing. We evaluated its impact on utilization and assessed postimplementation ordering appropriateness and antibiotic prescribing through targeted chart review.

    Methods

    We conducted a quasi-experimental interrupted time series (ITS) study across the Tufts Medicine healthcare system, a 1,039-bed system comprising one tertiary-care academic hospital and two community hospitals. The study period spanned August 2023 through July 2025, including 12 months before and after CDS implementation in August 2024. No other concurrent stewardship interventions or electronic health record changes affecting urine testing occurred during the study period.The CDS tool was integrated into the CPOE workflow for inpatient urinalysis alone (UA), urinalysis-with-reflex-to-culture (UARC), and urine culture alone (UCx), requiring providers to select a clinical indication prior to order completion. The CDS presented educational messaging on inappropriate indications for urine culturing but did not trigger indication-specific advice or warnings. For orders not meeting criteria for UARC or UCx, UA was available as an alternative. Indications were derived from institutional guidance aligned with national recommendations (Figure 1). Prior to implementation, clinicians were notified through a systemwide email that included screenshots of the CDS orders and ordering guidance, with targeted emails to department chairs to facilitate distribution.Figure 1.Figure 1 long description.Clinical decision support tool interface and indication selection for inpatient urine testing.A table detailing urine testing guidelines and criteria for hospitalized patients.Figure 1 long description.Clinical decision support tool interface and indication selection for inpatient urine testing.Urine testing data were extracted from the electronic health record and aggregated monthly. Patient-day denominators were obtained from hospital census data. Primary outcome was the monthly utilization rate per 1,000 patient-days for UA, UARC, and UCx. Secondary outcomes included trend(slope) changes in utilization following CDS implementation.Segmented regression was used to perform ITS analysis, estimating baseline trends, immediate level changes at implementation, and postintervention slope changes. Level changes are reported as tests per 1,000 patient-days and slope changes as the change per 1,000 patient-days per month, each with 95% confidence intervals(CI). Monthly testing rates were modeled assuming a normal distribution with an identity link. Statistical significance was defined as P < .05. Analyses were performed using SPSS version 25 (IBM, Armonk, NY, USA).We performed a patient-level chart review at Tufts Medical Center to assess ordering appropriateness and downstream antibiotic prescribing. We focused on UARC because it is the most frequently ordered and most commonly misordered urine test at our institution. We reviewed a random sample of 153 unique adult inpatients with UARC orders placed during April 2025. Repeat orders from the same patient were excluded. Two independent infectious-disease-trained reviewers (A.L.T., M.V.I.) applied predefined appropriateness criteria, piloted on a subset of cases prior to formal review, and assessed selected CDS indications, documentation of urinary symptoms or qualifying criteria, clinical justification for testing, and whether antibiotics were initiated for presumed urinary tract infection (UTI). Discrepancies were adjudicated by a third investigator (M.A.). This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Tufts Medical Center.

    Results

    During the study period, 124,762 urine tests were ordered across 225,614 patient-days. There were no significant preintervention trends for UA, UARC, or UCx.ITS analysis demonstrated an immediate increase in UA utilization after CDS implementation (41.4; 95% CI, 20.1 to 62.8), with no significant postintervention slope change (−2.8; 95% CI, −5.9 to 0.3). In contrast, UARC utilization showed an immediate decrease (−62.7; 95% CI, -−85.4 to −39.9), followed by a modest increase in postintervention slope (4.1; 95% CI, 0.8 to 7.4). UCx utilization also demonstrated an immediate decrease (−1.8; 95% CI, −2.9 to −0.7), with no significant postintervention slope change(−0.03; 95% CI, −0.2 to 0.1) (Figure 2; Supplemental Table 1).Figure 2.Monthly urine testing rates before and after implementation of clinical decision support tool at Tufts Medicine, August 2023–July 2025.Graphs showing urine testing rates over time.Monthly urine testing rates before and after implementation of clinical decision support tool at Tufts Medicine, August 2023–July 2025.Of the 153 reviewed UARC orders, 46.4% originated in the emergency department (ED), 41.2% in intensive care units, and 12.4% on inpatient floor units. Documentation supported appropriate testing in 9.9% of ED encounters, 19.2% of inpatient floor encounters, and 27.8% of intensive care unit encounters. Antibiotics for presumed UTI were initiated in 29 patients (19%), whereas only 9 (5.9%) had documentation consistent with symptomatic infection.

    Discussion

    Implementation of an indication-based CDS tool for inpatient urine testing was associated with immediate, intended reductions in UARC and UCx ordering. However, these effects were incomplete and not fully sustained. UARC utilization partially rebounded, and UA ordering increased immediately after implementation, suggesting substitution toward less restricted testing rather than a true reduction in low-value testing. Indication-based CDS alone was therefore insufficient to produce sustained, guideline-concordant practices in our setting.Several factors may explain these results. First, our intervention functioned as a required prompt without a hard stop, and softer interventions are more vulnerable to bypass or workaround behavior,4,5 potentially explaining the immediate reduction in culture-based testing without consistent improvement in appropriateness. Second, the rise in UA ordering suggests substitution to a less restricted test. For clinicians remain concerned about missing infection, indication-based prompts may shift ordering without changing the underlying diagnostic threshold, consistent with qualitative work identifying diagnostic uncertainty, fear of undertreatment, and ingrained practice norms as barriers to stewardship.6 Third, required CDS fields may also fail to capture clinical reasoning when the tool is perceived as administrative rather than a meaningful decision aid, as alert fatigue promotes routinized selection.7,8 In this context, requiring indication selection does not ensure accurate indication selection.Our audit findings reinforce this. Documentation-supported appropriateness remained low across inpatient settings, particularly in the ED, where prior work has identified ED ordering as a strong predictor of inappropriate urine culturing.9 Antibiotics for presumed UTI were often initiated without documented symptoms. These findings suggest that interventions targeting test ordering alone may have limited downstream effect unless paired with complementary strategies aimed at interpretation and prescribing, such as prospective audit and feedback.2,10This study has several limitations. It was a single healthcare system study, and chart review was limited to a sample of 153 postimplementation UARC orders at Tufts Medical Center, which may limit generalizability. Although our ITS design uses each period as its own control, accounting for stable or gradually changing population characteristics, we did not tabulate baseline characteristics across periods, and interrater agreement for the chart review was not formally assessed. Appropriateness assessments were based on chart documentation and may have unrecorded clinical reasoning. Lastly, because review was performed only after implementation, we could not directly compare pre and postintervention appropriateness.In conclusion, implementation of an indication-based CDS tool produced immediate reductions in culture-based urine testing, offset by test substitution, limited sustainability, low documentation-supported appropriateness, and antibiotic treatment without documented symptoms. These findings suggest that indication-based CDS, particularly without a hard stop or complementary stewardship measures, may be insufficient to achieve sustained improvement in urine testing and downstream prescribing. Multifaceted approaches combining diagnostic stewardship with behavioral, workflow, and prescribing-focused interventions are likely needed.

    Supporting information

    Valdez Imbert et al. supplementary material
    SDDr. Shira Doron
    Leading Voice

    Dr. Shira Doron

    Infectious Disease · Healthcare Epidemiology
    AdventHealth Orlando
    shira